Batteries Produdcts : page 1 | page 2 | page 3 | page 4 | page 5 | page 6 | page 7 | page 8 | page 9 | page 10 | page 11
Battery Information: FAQ | Battery Glossary | Internet-Resources.us

Performance Comparison of Various Rechargeable Batteries





About Rechargeableable Battery

There are five types of rechargeable batteries commercially available. The following table compares their performance and application. Currently the most popular rechargeable batteries are Ni-Cd, Ni-MH and Li-Ion in consumer electronic industry, which are among our major products.

Using rechargeable battery can save Environmental and save your money. For example, one AA size NiMH battery can be used at least 500 times and equal to 500 pcs AA alkaline battery, it cost you less than $0.002 for each time.

  Performance Comparison of various Rechargeable Batteries

Parameters

Lead acid

Ni-Cd

Ni-M-H

Liquid

Li-Ion

Polymer

Li-ion

Voltage (V)

2

1.2

1.2

3.6

3.6

Weight energy density (Wh/Kg)

35

50

80

125

170

Volume energy Density (Wh/l)

80

150

200

320

400

Cycle life (times)

300

500

500

800

1000

Selfdischarge
(%/ month)

0

25-30

30-35

6-9

2-5

Electrolyte state

Liquid

Liquid

Liquid

Liquid

Polymer Gel

Min. thickness

> 10 mm

>3mm

>3mm

>3mm

<1mm

Memory effect

no

yes

yes

No

No

Pollution

yes

yes

No

No

No

Production cost

lowest

Low

middle

High

Middle

Advantages

High drain current and low cost

Middle drain current and low cost, smaller volume

Middle drain current and cost, higher capacity

higher capacity and lighter weight

Highest capacity, lighter weight and flexible shaple

Disadvantages

Too heavy

Environmental not friendly

Higher self-discharge and weight

Low drain current and higher cost

Low drain current and very high cost

Applications

Car and lighting

Power tool, cordless phone and emergency lighting etc.

Toy, PDA,, MP3 and digital camera etc

Cellular phone and laptop computer

Labtop computers

 top of page


Nickel/Cadmium Cells

Anode: Cadmium

Cathode: Nickel oxyhydroxide Ni(OH)2

Electrolyte: Aqueous potassium hydroxide (KOH)

Applications: Calculators, digital cameras, pagers, lap tops, tape recorders, flashlights, medical devices (e.g., defibrillators), electric vehicles, space applications

The anode is nickel-plated, woven mesh, and the cathode is a cadmium-plated net. Since the cadmium is just a coating, this cell's negative environmental impact is often exaggerated. (Incidentally, cadmium is also used in TV tubes, some semiconductors, and as an orange-yellow dye for plastics.) The electrolyte, KOH, acts only as an ion conductor and does not contribute significantly to the cell's reaction. That's why not much electrolyte is needed, so this keeps the weight down. (NaOH is sometimes used as an electrolyte, which doesn't conduct as well, but also doesn't tend to leak out of the seal as much). Here are the cell reactions:

Reaction V vs SHE
Cd + 2OH- ?a> Cd(OH)2 + 2e- 0.81
NiO2 + 2H2O + 2e- ?a> Ni(OH)2 + 2OH- 0.49
Cd +NiO2 + 2H2O ?a> Cd(OH)2 + Ni(OH)2 1.30

Advantages include good performance in high-discharge and low-temperature applications. They also have long shelf and use life. Disadvantages are that they cost more than the lead-acid battery and have lower power densities. Possibly its most well-known limitation is a memory effect, where the cell retains the characteristics of the previous cycle.

This term refers to a temporary loss of cell capacity, which occurs when a cell is recharged without being fully discharged. This can cause cadmium hydroxide to passivate the electrode, or the battery to wear out. In the former case, a few cycles of discharging and charging the cell will help correct the problem, but may shorten the lifetime of the battery. The true memory effect comes from experience with a certain style of NiCad in space use, which were cycled within a few percent of discharge each time.

An important thing to know about "conditioning " a NiCd battery is that the deep discharge spoken of is not a discharge to zero volts, but to about 1 volt per cell.  top of page



Nickel/Metal Hydride (NiMH) Cells

Anode: Rare-earth or nickel alloys with many metals

Cathode: Nickel oxyhydroxide

Electrolyte: Potassium hydroxide

Applications: Cellular phones, camcorders, emergency backup lighting, power tools, laptops, portable, electric vehicles

This sealed cell is a hybrid of the NiCd and NiH2 cells. Previously, this battery was not available for commercial use because, although hydrogen has wonderful anodic qualities, it requires cell pressurization. Fortunately, in the late 1960s scientists discovered that some metal alloys (hydrides such as LiNi5 or ZrNi2) could store hydrogen atoms, which then could participate in reversible chemical reactions. In modern NiMH batteries, the anode consists of many metals alloys, including V, Ti, Zr, Ni, Cr, Co, and Fe.

Except for the anode, the NiMH cell very closely resembles the NiCd cell in construction. Even the voltage is virtually identical, at 1.2 volts, making the cells interchangeable in many applications. Here are the cell reactions:

Location Reactions Voltage
Anode MH + OH- ?a> M + H2O + e- 0.83
Cathode NiOOH + H2O + e- ?a> Ni(OH)2 + OH- 0.52
Overall NiOOH + MH ?a> Ni(OH)2 + M 1.35

The anodes used in these cells are complex alloys containing many metals, such as an alloy of V, Ti, Zr, Ni, Cr, Co, and (!) Fe. The underlying chemistry of these alloys and reasons for superior performance are not clearly understood, and the compositions are determined by empirical testing methods.

A very interesting fact about these alloys is that some metals absorb heat when absorbing hydrogen, and some give off heat when absorbing hydrogen. Both of these are bad for a battery, since we would like the hydrogen to move easily in and out without any energy transfer. The successful alloys are all mixtures of exothermic and endothermic metals to achieve this.


 top of page

Industrial Standard Cylindrical Battery Sizes

Cell Size Diameter (mm) Length (mm) NiCad Weight(grams) NiMH Weight(grams)
A Size Batteries
AAAA 8.4 40.2 10 10
4/3 AAAA 8.4 67 12-13 13
1/4 AAA 10.5 14 2.5-3.5 2.5-4
1/3 AAA 10.5 16 5.5 5.5
1/2 AAA 10.5 22   7
2/3 AAA 10.5 30 6-8 8-9
AAA36 10.5 36   11
4/5 AAA 10.5 37   11
AAA38 10.5 38   11
3/4 AAA 10.5 39.5 12 12
AAA42 10.5 42   12
AAA 10.5 44.5 10 13
5/4 AAA 10.5 50 14 15
L-AAA 10.5 50 13 14
4/3 AAA 10.5 67 17 18
5/3 AAA 10.5 67 19 19
LL-AAA 10.5 67 17 18
3/2 AAA 10.5 67 19 20
6/4 AAA 10.5 67 20 20
7/5 AAA 10.5 66.5 15 15
7/4 AAA 10.5 76 19 20-21
7/3 AAA 10.5 80   23
SL AAA 10.5 80   23
1/3 AA 14.2 17.5 6.5 7
1/2 AA 14.2 30 12 15
2/3 AA 14.2 28.7 13-15 13-16
4/5 AA 14.2 43 20 22
AA 14.2 50 21 27
AA flat top 14.2 48 21 27
5/4 AA
14.2
64.5   29
L-AA 14.2 65 29 30
4/3 AA 14.2 65.2 30 30
7/5 AA 14.2 70 29 39
1/3 A 17 21    
1/2 A 17 25 17 21
2/3 A 17 28.5 18-20 20-23
4/5 A 17 43 26-31 32-35
A 17 50 32 40
4/3 A 17 67 50 55
L-A 17 67 48 53
7/5 A 17 70 44.8 56
Fat A 18 50 38 42
4/3 Fat A 18 67 56 60
L-Fat A 18 67 55 60
Sub C Size Batteries
1/2 SC 23 26 30  
2/3 SC 23 28 25 28
4/5 SC 23 34 38 42
SC (sub C) 23 43 52 55
5/4 Sub C 23 49.5 65-67 70
4/3 SC 23 50 60 66
L-SC 23 50 57 63
C Size Batteries
1/2 C 26 24 31 34
3/5 C 26 30 40 44
2/3 C 26 31 45 50
C 26 46 72 80
5/4 C 26 58 90 100
D Size Batteries
1/2 D 33 37 81-84 81
2/3 D 33 43.4 98-105 115
D 33 58 105-145 105-160
4/3 D 33 89 140-190 175
3/2 D 33 90.3 195-236 240
F Size Batteries
F 33 91.2 231 255
SF (super F) 41.4 89.1 393 425
  • Diameter & Length can vary as much as 0.1mm~1 mm between different manufacturers
  • Weight of a cell depends on manufacturer The purpose of the weight column is to give a feel for how heavy a cell will be. Your results may vary. top of page


 

This Table is the intellectual property of our affiliate vendor, BatterySpace.com (copyright 2004)